holy and unholy? Which is the issue? Well, the real question would be “the issue for what?” Because holy or unholy is the issue of sin, and our need for a savior. But good or bad is about behavior and that is where our discipline must be focused. If I try to parent my children in a way that addresses their holiness as primary I am playing God. If I try to parent my children by assessing whether their behavior is good or bad (or, to put it another way, acceptable or unacceptable) then I can be their parent. That doesn’t mean that I don’t teach *about* holiness. That is the entire context of my parenting. Deuteronomy tells me to teach these things (Torah/God’s Standard) to my children daily, thinking of them when I sit in our house, walk by the way, lie down, and rise up. And Proverbs assures me that if I train (better translated “steep”) them in the way they should go (again, Torah) when they are old they will not depart from it. Why? Because it will be all they know and to reject it requires rejecting their entire existence.
There are lots of really good people who will go to hell. Why? Because they are unholy. And some bad acting people who will be in heaven. Why? Because despite their human struggles they have Jesus’ atoning blood covering their sins and they are holy in his eyes. This is at the heart of why we are told to not judge our neighbor. We can only judge good or bad. We cannot see into the heart to judge holy or unholy.
So I model holiness; teach holiness; guide into holiness. And I discipline/teach behavior. In the context of discipline this means I must judge whether a behavior is good or bad. This is different from judging the heart (holy/unholy)–this is a judging that we must do with one another. This is the judging that signals to us, “This is simply not okay and must be addressed.” But it does not indicate, because we can’t judge it, holiness or unholiness. This is where many people get stuck and the parenting experts swoop in to explain it.
See, they would say that bad behavior IS unholiness. And, therefore, you must address the unholiness in order to demand the behavior be good. But this is confusing issues. Does the child who was previously unholy because of bad behavior suddenly become holy because of good behavior? Has your correction of their behavior changed their standing before God?
Holy or Unholy is how they stand before God. It is what only Jesus, using the Holy Spirit, is addressing in our children’s lives. And it is through grace that God saves us and our children.
Good or bad is how they stand before us. It is the area in which WE can offer them grace. And the statement “people who feel good act good; people who feel bad act bad” is the means through which we can offer them grace. When we remember this simple truism we can be reminded to address the feelings before we address the behavior. If a child is operating out of their feelings it is a waste of time to attempt to address the behavior before addressing the feelings. Consider the feelings the roadblock to addressing the behavior. If the roadblock of feelings is removed it is likely the behavior will resolve itself.
Just as an example, let’s say two children are fighting. Why? Because she hit me. Why? Because he took my toy. Why? In fact, most situations can be pursued back through both children for many “turns” of what motivated their behavior. And the precipitating cause will always justify to a child the reaction they thought was appropriate. When we are willing to entertain that their “reason”, no matter how childish to us, is valid to them, we can see that they were not just being “mean” or “rude” or even “sinful”. They are being children. It takes a moment to reflect the feeling, validate the emotions, calm the child, and then address the wrong of the behavior. Giving them that moment, that effort, is grace.
Jesus didn’t come to us and call us all sinners and remind us we were doomed to hell and make sure we knew how lucky mankind was that he was willing to come and take care of that problem of sin–and how grateful we must be. He actually came as one of us, faced the problems we face, overcame them and modeled for us how to do it according to the manual. He loved us, he died for us–and after feeding, healing, loving and mentoring us. Then, when we are able to love him because he first loved us, he steps up and dies–and asks us to let that death take the place of the one we owe. That is grace.
Grace sees beyond the sin, beyond the unholiness, through the bad behavior, and to the heart of the person who needs love and grace. Whether we are the one who deals with holiness (which we aren’t, that is God
) or the one who deals with bad behavior (as the parents), when grace is applied, we shepherd the heart.